irish-sid vs EVE - Sig Duel Tournament 2 - Round 2

.

Sig 1



Sig 2


​

Feel Free To Leave Comments​

​

.

 

voted!
Both great, but I`d actually prefer a mixture
First one should be a little sharper, whereas the second should be a little darker.
:2cent:

 

oh this is tough. both sigs are fantastic and for entirely different reasons. i can't really fault either of them for anything but i'm gonna go with #2 for the composition and all the layers in the background. batman proving popular this round!

 

Voted.

 

love the look of the first one but holy crap the second one just floored me.

 

Both are fantastic!
But number 2 is even fantasticer

 

voted, i like the first one

 

I like sig 1 but like sig 2 even more.

 

This is damn hard...both rock. But I like #1 slightly more

 

1 just needed some contrast and maybe a different txt color
2 would have been better a bit darker

It's a toss up because I'm pretty sick of Joker on everything.
#2 is just better though in some respects.

I'll have to think about it and vote later.

in the end, I went I had to go with #2

If the txt had been white in #1 I would have voted for it

 

I went with #1.

I liked #1 over #2, and I might have given it to #2 because the text placement on #1 is poor, but I don't like what #2 did either, so with the text excluded from both, #1 was the better choice for me.

Great work either way.

 

This is almost too close to call, both are very very well executed sigs.

#1 has a really seamless feel to it with the source pic and the abstract background, so that's really well done, I also like the border and colors used. One thing I think could have been changed is the black text as it seems to lose it's clarity once it goes into the black background on the left.

#2 is pretty astonishing, I love the 2 character sources and their placement, and the colorful render between them is truly original. On top of all this the overlaying parts that form the background really finish it off perfectly. Although I was a little put off by the white border, I don't know whether I care for that or not.

But after much deliberation I had to give my vote to #2

 

I like 1.

Both are cool though.

 

I Think They Both Suck! lol Just Kidding, Great Work! Voted.......

 

Both great sigs with very minor things I'm not so keen on. I love the grittiness of number one but I'm not a fan of the black text. Number 2 is brilliantly put together but for me is a little too clean for that particular film, if that makes any sense. I went for 1 in the end just because I thought it was a slightly more interesting take on the film.

 

Both are very good.......I can't decide.................

 

I'm going to wait and see.........think this one is gonna be close.........BOTH are excellent work!

 

Both are awesome
Ended up voting for sig 2

 

Both are excellent.

 

I think the lesson to be learned from the above posts is that these sigs are both incredible
#2 blew me away though I had to go with it. Great job guys